
I've been using the second generation Rock Band Stratocaster for a few weeks now, and I'm finally ready to give a verdict on it. I never used the first version guitar, instead using the Guitar Hero 3 wireless Les Paul. The positive reviews for the new guitar lead me to try it out at best buy and eventually pick one up. Since I used the Les Paul for so long, much of this review will be comparing the two.
First thing you will notice is the aesthetics - this guitar looks great. The two tone wood finish make it the most realistic looking fake plastic guitar on the market. The buttons are placed such that it looks like a real Strat, which is a nice touch - but it makes for awkward placement of the whammy bar (more on that later).
So it looks good, but how does it play? Well depending on where you are coming from you might have mixed results. First, the buttons are not raised up from the fretboard like all previous Guitar Hero controllers, they are flush on the neck which may trip you up if you are used to raised buttons. Once you get used to it though it feels natural, and it's actually easier to move your hand up the neck to play the orange note. The buttons are also more closely spaced, which is good and bad. When I first started playing on the Strat I was accidentally pushing two buttons at once because of the spacing, but once I got a feel for it I was able to move up and down much faster, plus green/orange chords are much easier than with the Les Paul.
The strum bar is built for speed and as a result, it's
really sensitive. I'm used to resting my thumb on the strum bar when not actually playing but I've found that this is unwise since even a small movement of the bar can cause a strum. On the positive side, strumming fast sections is much, much easier than with the Les Paul. Since Rock Band 2 features many fast strum songs, this is a good thing. The strum bar is also very quiet, with the slightest of click when strummed, which is nice when you are trying to jam with the music and not the clicking of the bar.
So it's all good right? Well, not everything. The whammy bar is placed directly below the strum bar when you stand the guitar straight up and down. This is a really unnatural place for the bar to be, making it really tough to reach, especially when you need to get to it quickly. The Les Paul's whammy bar is really perfect, directly underneath your hand for really quick access. I would say this is the only aspect of the Les Paul that is clearly superior to the Strat. I applaud
Harmonix for making a realistic looking controller, but I wish they wold have modified this aspect of the design for ease of use.
Overall I'm very happy with the guitar, my scores are up overall, my solos are improving, and fast notes/chords are much easier to manage now. It is worth the price, especially from
Deep Discount where it is $59.00 shipped.